Barley Island Brewing

Brewpub in Noblesville, Indiana, United States 🇺🇸
Associated Venue: Barley Island Brewing Company - Out of business

Closed in 2022

Contact
639 Conner St, Noblesville, IN, 46060, United States

     Show


6.9/10 Appearance 8 Aroma 6 Flavor 7 Texture 8 Overall 6.5
Bottled - rich dark pour with small tan head - roasty, coffee aroma - fairly strong, dry, dark chocolate taste - really quite pleasant - a little thin near the finish, but otherwise a nice, drinkable stout.
Tried from Bottle on 28 May 2006 at 22:11

6.4/10 Appearance 8 Aroma 7 Flavor 6 Texture 6 Overall 5.5
22 oz bottle - Pours very dark brown with a big, enduring head. It has a heavy bourbon aroma. The flavor is dry roasted malts and quite a bit of bourbon. There’s a moderate body with okay carbonation. The finish is unremarkable. It loses something overall. I thought the bourbon dominated too much, not because there was too much bourbon necessarily, but rather because there wasn’t enough else going on. It’s alright, but drinking my way through the whole bomber I got tired of it.
Tried from Bottle on 05 May 2006 at 22:16

6/10 Appearance 6 Aroma 6 Flavor 6 Texture 6 Overall 6
Near black colour with a big head. Quite fizzy, obscuring some chocolatey accents. Mainly malty with light chocolate but I can’t move past the fizz (I never can).
Tried from Can on 16 Mar 2006 at 01:14

4.6/10 Appearance 8 Aroma 5 Flavor 3 Texture 4 Overall 4.5
Almost black colour. Head is light but also rocky. The aroma is a bit woody, roasty and chocolatey. The body is way too fizzy and overwhelmingly woody.
Tried on 09 Mar 2006 at 00:26

6.5/10 Appearance 6 Aroma 7 Flavor 7 Texture 6 Overall 6
Tried on 23 Feb 2006 at 13:41

5.8/10 Appearance 4 Aroma 6 Flavor 6 Texture 6 Overall 6
Hazy blonde colour. Aroma of lemon, coriander, light maltiness. Sweet and soft with a flowery, honeyish nature and nutmeggy accent.
Tried on 11 Feb 2006 at 10:59

4.4/10 Appearance 8 Aroma 4 Flavor 4 Texture 4 Overall 3.5
2005 bottle shared with SuIIy on 11/23/05. The bottle says it is unfiltered and unpasteurized, but yet, the beer pours the most fizzy, clear thing I have seen lately. If this isn’t forced carbonation, than it’s the strangest natural carbonation I’ve ever experienced. Deep cola brown, somewhat dull, not much in the auburn-red tinged department, as some deeper colored stouts have. Tan-beige head is mountainous and very very slow to recede. Lacing present. Aroma of straight bourbon, dry and lightly alcoholic, with light vanilla and very dry wood. Hints of baker’s chocolate, some light yeast and very little else. No sweet malt, no creamy oat-like notes, no hops. Flavor is full bourbon. Hints of peanut skins, salt, seltzer water and alcohol. Pure bourbon, dry wood and light roast. It’s not that the bourbon is overdone here, it’s just that the beer is underdone. No malt sugars, little if any chocolate or roast. Body seems very filtered, though they say it is not. Carbonation is omnipresent, sharp, obtrusive and very high. Texture is watery, loose, prickly and thin on end. As it warms, the aroma takes on a note of glue or hot plastic.
Tried from Bottle on 25 Nov 2005 at 10:43

4.9/10 Appearance 8 Aroma 6 Flavor 4 Texture 4 Overall 3.5
Totally opaque pour with a massive, long lasting tan head - aroma of bourbon, vanilla, oak, alcohol - a bit thin on the palate - not many oatmeal stout characteristics besides a hint of lactose - mostly, the wood and bourbon from the barrel overpower whatever other flavors the beer has - if you want a similar experience, soak a tongue depressor in whiskey and suck on it.
Tried on 15 Jul 2005 at 20:20

5.4/10 Appearance 6 Aroma 5 Flavor 6 Texture 4 Overall 5.5
Bottle from IN. Light hazy brown ale, with a smalle big bubbled off white head. Light malty aroma with a hint of nuts and hops. Very fresh malts, grainy and some grassy german style hops. Nuts come out as beer warms up. Lighter bodied. More like a Vienna.
Tried from Bottle on 18 Dec 2004 at 17:27

7/10 Appearance 8 Aroma 7 Flavor 7 Texture 6 Overall 7
Deep chestnut brown body, thin light tan head. Dry chocolate, mocha, and marshmallow aroma, quite toasty. Sharp chocolate flavor, mocha, and toast with some roasted acidity. Relatively thin-bodied with a decent flavor profile. Bitter roasted malt finish. Wood and even a hint of vanilla peek through the roasted malts; I understand why barrel-aging this beer was so successful.
Tried on 23 Nov 2004 at 14:25