South Hill Cider

Cidery in Ithaca, New York, United States 🇺🇸

Established in 2004

Contact
550 Sandbank Road, Ithaca, NY, 14850, United States
Description
Our orchard is planted on a peaceful hilltop as part of a harmonious ecosystem that relies on diversity and fertility as its foundation. South Hill Cider produces ciders with individuality, quality, and elegance reflecting the terroir of our beautiful Finger Lakes region.
Steve Selin, the cidermaker, apple picker, and community orchardist has been bottling his own cider since 2004. Collaborating with neighbors to help maintain and reclaim wild trees and forgotten orchards for use in cider making has been a labor of love for years ~ see the Fingerlakes Apple Tree Project. The apples from these trees, plus bittersweet and heirloom apples from other small orchards, enable us to give every bottle of cider the solid foundation needed for world-class ciders.
Living just four miles south of the Ithaca Commons, Steve and his family have been collaborating with an adjoining landowner to allow Steve to plow these fallow fields and to plant an orchard of cider apples. This land, being so close to Downtown Ithaca, is under intense development pressure. In 2014 Steve helped the landowner to protect his land with a Conservation Easement, which will protect the land from subdivision and development in perpetuity. The land adjoins 182 acres of Finger Lakes Land Trust and Cornell Preserves and is located on the Finger Lakes Trail.

     Show


6.2
Appearance - 6 | Aroma - 8 | Flavor - 5 | Texture - 8 | Overall - 5

Shit is way off. Bottle club, Lo-ball @home. Mostly clear, mellow gold, jellied pour. Minerally, minty, bittersweet, hot laundry, dry nose. Oxidized, grainy, Sidra rubber funk, lemon, bittersweet dirt, a tart savior of a middle, lingering medium strong pith. It starts to dissipate with time, but the front end is just really nasty & nothing like last year. Crispy pet-nat, nice texture, its just oxidized & funky in a bad way. Bad bugs.

Tried from Bottle on 17 Jun 2023 at 02:02


7.6
Appearance - 6 | Aroma - 7 | Flavor - 8 | Texture - 10 | Overall - 7.5

Clear 750 bottle from their cider club. Lo-ball back @home. Clear, faint straw gold, if that, very active. Pure cava nose. That's all, this is cava. Thin, bittersharp, champagne yeast, Cava, pineapple & sulfites, lingering pith, minerally, nearly-almost dry, not too astringent, harsh booze, harsher carbonation. Needs more. Bubbly.

Tried from Bottle on 17 Jun 2023 at 01:05


7.8
Appearance - 4 | Aroma - 6 | Flavor - 9 | Texture - 10 | Overall - 9

Vintage bottle from their cider shop. Shipped with the cider club box & a bit of a nap in the basement. Cork is stamped: 2-20. Pint glass @home. Serious bottle bomb all over my tablet. Clear, medium bright gold, soda froth, very active. Fresh dessert apples, soap, chalk, building astringency, champagne, pungent-earthy florals(like dirty marigolds). Extra crispy, strong orange-lemon-hay front end. Middle is all hyper-astringent core, fresh & pithy bitter, sorta sour, hyper dry, big lingering acid belly. Finish is skin, sulfites & sour grapefruit. Big soda carbonation, boozy, dusty texture. Bracing, classic South Hill. Bottle bomb just made me angry.

Tried from Bottle on 22 Mar 2023 at 01:05


8.8
Appearance - 10 | Aroma - 7 | Flavor - 10 | Texture - 8 | Overall - 9

Bottle from their cider club, asleep in the basement all winter. Big drop in abv from last year, different apples or do ambient yeasts also suffer from long-haul covid? Frothy pint glass pour @home. Dark, orange-y copper, suspended & jellied. Smells of serious old wood. Sweat, dried flowers, sour turnip basement, dust. Really tasty. Caramelized, with a bitter upfront lip. Savory veg, minerally, mellow Aspirin, herbal & oily, skin isn't very astringent but lingers forever. Low to medium low carbonation, fatty texture, glaring background acidity, just a twinge of tartness, maybe a bit too much residual sugar, but the rich finish is cut off with confirming popsicle stick dryness. Super tasty.

Tried from Bottle on 21 Mar 2023 at 23:14


8
Appearance - 8 | Aroma - 9 | Flavor - 8 | Texture - 8 | Overall - 7

Bottle from their cider club. Mojito glass @home. Jellied, oily, medium, sparkly gold. Saline & earth nose. Dusty, quice-like, rose, melon, not too bold. Super crispy. Earthy & subtly savory. Big bowl of English bitters & biting American apples. Peppery, ginger ale. A bit too yeasty, almost like a garlic powder finish. Very dry. Boozy with more acid than I expected. Conflicted. Pretty good but feel this should be great.

Tried from Bottle on 18 Mar 2023 at 02:58


7.5
Appearance - 8 | Aroma - 7 | Flavor - 8 | Texture - 8 | Overall - 7

Still bottle from their bottle club. Mojito glass @home. Clear, slightly dull, medium gold. Sharp skin, lemoncello, macerated, green strawberry, corn, melon rind. Sharp & bitter-tart. Sour cherry, sour kiwi, lime, gentle pith, steel. Empty at times. Clenching, dry Lipton tea finish. Almost thin, slightly creamy, quenching, boozy enough. Tasty, but prefer the newer stuff.

Tried from Bottle on 10 Mar 2023 at 22:23


9
Appearance - 10 | Aroma - 10 | Flavor - 9 | Texture - 8 | Overall - 8

Cork & cage from their very solid cider club. Stemless wine glass in my makeshift office @home. Clear, medium, oily, active gold. Quick-hitting, bleached soda head. An estate wine with more of a potluck feel. Definite honey, cooked apple, savory smoke, butter, mellow pie spice. Round & honeyed upfront, it branches out with the big acidity South Hill is known for, sharp & stab-y. Middle is some slight savoriness, some butter, but more so the English earthiness they have introduced more & more. Soda bread. Salt. Mellow yeasty finish. Cheese? Hidden acid all around. Cutting crispness. Dusty feel. Low tart, high acid. Big for just 7.6%. Complex but very sloshable. Great.

Tried on 10 Mar 2023 at 04:15


7.6
Appearance - 8 | Aroma - 6 | Flavor - 8 | Texture - 10 | Overall - 7.5

Clear bottle from their cider club. Stemless wineglass @home. Watermelon peach sunset combo color, filtered, active & fizzy. Waxy apple, blush wine floral, grape skin, subliminal orange. Grape-y on the front, hibiscus floral sweetness makes me doubt the 0% RS. Middle on is bitter-tart & half-tannic apple that lingers through the softly earthy & soapy finish. Not the most complex, but very summery & fresh. Overall pretty thin with extra sizzling carbonated. Abv is on the stiffer side & punches through what's left of dinner.

Tried from Bottle on 10 Mar 2023 at 02:08


8.2
Appearance - 6 | Aroma - 9 | Flavor - 9 | Texture - 6 | Overall - 9

I snuck a bottle away of this at my in-laws place one visit, just in case. It survived a few consolidations & clean-ups & give backs. I finally popped it because we now live so close by. Had no idea they recently stopped producing it. Cork seems to think this is a 2017 bottle. I probably got this from a Christmas market at the now defunct Brooklyn Cider House location in Bushwick(which no one ever added or rated!). Mojito glass @home. Clear, glassy, 14k gold, quick hitting soda head. Pineapple juice, apple-lemon pie tart, sharp preserves, fresh cut wood. Taste is a strong, acidic, bittersweet winey profile, laced with some earthy aromatics. Lots of familiar sharp & semi-sweet flavors, fermented dry. A touch smokey, thin & quite bourbon-y with a hint of vanilla & apple core rounding to creamy at the end. Strong, brash acidity, was defacto flavor profile for South Hill for many years. Aged as it is, it is still quite bold. Thin, acidic, warm bourbon. Very tasty.

Tried from Bottle on 03 Jan 2023 at 04:22


7.9
Appearance - 6 | Aroma - 10 | Flavor - 8 | Texture - 6 | Overall - 7.5

Bottle from their cider club. Quince is my jam. Duvel glass @home. Foamy, lumpy, hazy pale gold pour. Strong apricot & pineapple nose, curious veg, spice, wax. Amazing nose. Super tropical, pineapple & onion sweetness. Juicy. Leafy backside, young funk, lime, minerals, continued pineapple, salt. Juicy, wet, lingering. Though I didn't get that everlasting pith dryness that I associate with quince. Tasty.

Tried from Bottle on 03 Jan 2023 at 02:53