7.2/10
—
Appearance 10
Aroma 7
Flavor 7
Texture 6
Overall 7
2000 bottle consumed 11/04. Thanks to Mike (eydrinkale) for the bottle. Wow. Amazingly murky pour, looks like melted caramel with some toffee mixed in. Light beige head, obviously unfiltered and bottle conditioned. . . .which means, this has aged spectacularly! You can sense it as soon as you smell it; light yeast, dates, peaches, raisins, chewy caramel, a touch of earth and plenty of wonderfully rich toffee/malt feel. Flavor is full, body is medium-full and this thing just pours on the good qualities. Chewy and rich, but yet balanced and not overbearing. Caramel, figs, toffee, raisins. If you mixed a Harvey’s Elizabethan with Old Numbskull, I’d imagine it to turn out something like this. Wonderful qualities from the yeast (phenols and a dusty vintage quality). At four years old, the flavor hasnt suffered. I left a glass of this out overnight and in the morning, the body was as strong as ever. Fantastic!! English barleywines are truly divine!
2001 bottle consumed Feb 2005 Yikes, it’s amazing to see the changes in just one year. Sourish lactic notes, much higher alpha hops than the 2000. More loose of a body, with less fruity yeast. Bitter roast astringency, heavily thin on the finish. 6/5/5/2/11
Final score is an average of the two.
Tried
from Bottle
on 15 Nov 2004
at 08:29