Caribbean Chocolate Cake - Salted Cherry
Siren Craft Brew in Finchampstead, Berkshire, England 🏴
Stout - Foreign / Extra Regular|
Score
7.44
|
|
One of two wildcards this year is a very special Salted Cherry edition, you could say this is a coming together of a Caribbean Chocolate Cake and a Black Forest Gateau. With slightly less cacao than the original, the beer opens up to allow the cherry to come through. We’re using a blend of Montmorency, Morello and Balaton cherries which add acidity and tartness along with the delicious compote vibe, with everything then lifted again by Pink Himalayan Sea Salt. The combination of ingredients is playful on the palate, with each element taking turns to lure you into thinking it’s the star of the show. We love how salt changes the expression of the chocolate, while also changing the mouthfeel of the beer in a great way.
Sign up to add a tick or review
7.4/10
—
Appearance 7
Aroma 7
Flavor 7
Texture 8
Overall 8
Can Etre Gourmet 2026-01-31 Göteborg
AR: sour cherries, dark chocolate, dry
AP: dark brown, frothy wee brown head
F: sour cherries, dark chocolate, dry
AR: sour cherries, dark chocolate, dry
AP: dark brown, frothy wee brown head
F: sour cherries, dark chocolate, dry
Tried
from Can
from Etre Gourmet (webshop)
on 31 Jan 2026
at 19:10
7/10
Tried
from Can
on 07 Feb 2025
at 18:23
7.3/10
—
Appearance 7
Aroma 7.5
Flavor 7.5
Texture 6
Overall 7.5
Tip Tap draught, 1/31/25.
Dark. Little head.
Nose has plentiful, meaty cherry juice and skin notes with a lightly charred chocolate. No excess sugar or alcohol.
Wow this is shockingly dry. Maybe even too much so? Not all that much body though the flavors are authentic and the salt gives a little slickness and savoriness. Lots of tart cherry juice with dark chocolate and biscuit and toast lingering.
Dark. Little head.
Nose has plentiful, meaty cherry juice and skin notes with a lightly charred chocolate. No excess sugar or alcohol.
Wow this is shockingly dry. Maybe even too much so? Not all that much body though the flavors are authentic and the salt gives a little slickness and savoriness. Lots of tart cherry juice with dark chocolate and biscuit and toast lingering.
Tried
from Draft
at
The Tip Tap Room
on 02 Feb 2025
at 19:57
7.6/10
LCI from 8x8 18-20 October. I’m not getting the salinity, but a good beer as always in this series.
Tried
from Draft
on 31 Dec 2024
at 20:49
7.6/10
—
Appearance 8
Aroma 7
Flavor 8
Texture 8
Overall 7.5
Can on the train from Bingohame to Tamworth, from an online peddler whom I can't recall, 06/09/24. Black with a big khaki head that stays for the show. Nose is dark chocolate, light spice, dark malts, cherry skins. Taste comprises chocolate, light roasted bite, salted caramel, cherry stone, spice balance. Medium bodied with bite, fine carbonation, semi drying close. Decent.
Tried
from Can
on 29 Dec 2024
at 11:59
7.4/10
—
Appearance 8
Aroma 7
Flavor 7
Texture 8
Overall 7.5
Can courtesy of Geraint and Helen (cheers you two!) had this, Tuesday 3rd December 2024 in the company of Dad and Pauline at Dad's Rawson Green, Kilburn, Derbyshire. Pours pitch large light beige head. It's both tart and sweet, roasty with bitter cocoa and tart fruitiness. Nice carbonation, nice mouthfeel, the saltiness is there but not hugely, cherries noted but well integrated. Good.
Tried
from Can
on 03 Dec 2024
at 21:18
7.9/10
—
Appearance 8
Aroma 8
Flavor 8
Texture 8
Overall 7.5
Growler fill from the Low Cost Beer online shop. Pours black with a thick beige head. Aromas of chocolate, cherry, light salt and wood. Taste has cakey coffee, salted chocolate, faint fruit and liquorice. There's a lot going on. Dry finish.
Tried
from Growler
on 11 Sep 2024
at 19:39
7.5/10
Kind of weird concept for me. But it’s interesting. Spicy, roasty, chocolate, touch of cherry. Salt. Not sure it’s the best combination but it’s nice.
Tried
on 20 Aug 2024
at 12:40
7.4/10
—
Appearance 8
Aroma 7
Flavor 7
Texture 8
Overall 7.5
Can at home in Hackney - picked up from HOTM. Pours black-brown with a dense, frothy mocha topping. Medium sweet flavour with decent roast, mellow berry notes, a little dry cocoa. Light to medium bodied with massaging carbonation. Pretty well balanced finish, more dry cocoa, aged berries, a little earth, dry roast. Very drinkable stuff.
Tried
from Can
on 24 Jul 2024
at 21:14
7.5/10
—
Appearance 7
Aroma 8
Flavor 8
Texture 8
Overall 6.5
One of a few dozens of variations on one of Siren's biggest hits, the Caribbean Chocolate Cake series of flavoured stouts, this time with three (!) varieties of cherries, sea salt, cocoa nibs and - oddly - cypress. Thick and creamy, membrane-lacing, dense, brownish mocha-beige, firm head on a black beer with burgundy tinge only visible at the edges. Aroma of dark chocolate, green coffee beans, salted caramel to even salmiak, concentrated cherry juice or ripe black cherries, plum wine, espresso, praliné, 'framboise' filling in a chocolate bar, ripe blue grapes, prunes, raisin bread, melting mocha ice cream, shoe polish, coffee grounds and indeed a volatile but very recognisable whiff of cypress. Sweet, dense onset with a clear sourish streak from the fruit, the whole combining lively sweet-sour black cherries with impressions of blackberries, figs and raisins, quite challenging early on; medium carb, very full and oily mouthfeel with soft velvety oats effect, thick layers of dark chocolate, toffee and walnut paste, sweet with a bitterish edge, but also showing the announced saltiness at its edges (fortunately not too strongly so) as in salmiak or salted caramel. Added cocoa does what it is supposed to do, namely deeping the chocolatey effect but taking it in a bittering kind of way, almost overpowering the sweetness from the lactose; above this all, this 'zingy' sourishness of actual dark fruit hovers, clashing a bit with the saltiness, sweetness and bitterness. The finish tries to tie everything together with moderate success, bringing forward a coffee-like roasted bitterness and warming gin-like alcohol effect along with peppery hop bitterness - but the cocoa reigns supreme, with the cypress being only a vague echo at this point. The cherries, meanwhile, still hold strong as well, continuing to effectuate their sourish, juicy fruitiness which, in the end, does indeed feel like a 'Black Forest gateau' when it finally fuses with the cocoa and toffee aspects, including the cocoa bitterishness. That pungent sourish fruitiness of the cherries in any case accompanies this odd and somewhat contrived beer's 'flavour parcours' from the first sip till the very end - but does so in an admittedly elegant way. Not the easiest one around - a lot is happening here, perhaps even a tad too much, but compared with the justly praised original, it does show the promised saltiness, cherry fruitiness (and tartness) and piney cypress aromas, though the latter are completely overshadowed by the other flavours. Too many things are happening here at the same time with unsurprisingly confusing effect, but it sure is an entertaining beer to drink. As for style designations: Siren calls this 'exotic' so I guess foreign stout is the obvious category springing to mind, but this concoction has very little or nothing to do with 'historical' foreign stout - this is, in fact, just another pastry stout trying to be original.
Tried
on 08 Jun 2024
at 01:05