First let me say that a s'mores beer does not sound very appealing, even my better half, that loves smores, wouldn't even taste it. It s a bottle from saranac, so why not try? I have liked many of sarry's offerings over the last two decades and most were quite acceptable. I'd say sarry is one of the original companies that saw the profit in craft beer, it was their idea! WTF! YES! Smell is alarming, its quite sweet, almost like artificial smores from the fire. Aroma is sweet and candy perfume. Big shady dark beer, really dark brown presentation for he eye. Once I get over the smell, I tried a sip; it was coconut laced sweet cloying porter. And then that alarming thang comes in and supports the sweet near-cloying taste. Could not do another of these sweet dark coconut chocolate bombs, so one sided with sweetness and coconuts, shredded processed coconuts that is. One big sweet candy thicker mouth coating beer tasting experience. Come - on, you really want to call this a porter? More like a spiced veggie fruit nut kind of brew. Not a good representation of porter, heheh. JMHO, HAH