Fire Island Beer Company

Client Brewer in Bay Shore, New York, United States 🇺🇸

Closed in 2018

Contact
25 Drexel Dr, Bay Shore, NY, 11706, United States

     Show


7.1/10 Appearance 6 Aroma 8 Flavor 8 Texture 4 Overall 7.5
Location: Draft at Grand Cru in Rhinebeck - 10/1/11

Aroma: This one has a big nose with pumpkin and lots of spice (nutmeg, cinnamon, etc...)
Appearance: This brew pours into the glass a dark orange with a decent sized beige head
Flavor: Tastes right on with the nose, lots of spice flavors mostly, finishes with a touch of earthy hop
Palate: It is medium bodied, it has a quite fizzy feel, and it drys out a bit as the finish tingles on the tongue
Overall Impression: This one had a big spice/pumpkin flavor and nose, which I quite enjoyed. The plus carbonation was really the only "downfall" I had with this one, and it isn't really that big a detraction. I thought this was an enjoyable beer, and a very nice example of style, but I tend to be a big fan of this style in general.
Tried from Draft on 02 Oct 2011 at 11:11

6.6/10 Appearance 6 Aroma 6 Flavor 7 Texture 6 Overall 7.5
Bottle. Amber beer with a dark cream colored head. Malt and light citrus aroma. Grapefruit and light summer fruit flavor. Medium bodied. Good bitterness. Grapefruit and pine lingers with light summer fruit and light caramel.
Tried from Bottle on 20 Jul 2011 at 09:16

7.2/10 Appearance 8 Aroma 7 Flavor 7 Texture 8 Overall 7
12 oz bottle-thanks Justin for sharing-pours a foamy light tan head and copper color. Aroma is medium malt-roasty, some spice. Taste is medium malt-roasty, some spice hops. Medium body. 3.6 Doesnt come across as an ASA, I didnt deduct for that. It is quaffable!
Tried from Bottle on 26 Jun 2011 at 10:22

6/10 Appearance 6 Aroma 6 Flavor 6 Texture 6 Overall 6
Bottle at John’s tasting. Pours reddish brown. Tan head. Clear. Nose of candi sugar, hops, malt and grain. Taste of candi sugar, caramel malt and dry spicy hop finish.
Tried from Bottle on 17 Mar 2011 at 21:33

6.1/10 Appearance 6 Aroma 6 Flavor 6 Texture 6 Overall 6.5
Location: Sampled at the NY Brewfest on Governor's Island, 6/19/10

Overall Impression: My second Fire Island beer of the brewfest (I also had a Red Wagon IPA, but I had rated that one prior to the event). Anyway, there isn't much to say about this one, other then it is a very OK beer.
Tried on 14 Nov 2010 at 17:21

5.5/10 Appearance 8 Aroma 4 Flavor 5 Texture 6 Overall 6
Bottle from Half Time. Pours copper. Off-white head. Aroma seems diacetyl. Flavor is bitter with roast malt. Seems a bit buttery. Interferes with hop id. Maybe floral/citrus? Even so it’s quite drinkable.
Tried from Bottle on 18 Oct 2010 at 18:23

3.5/10 Appearance 4 Aroma 3 Flavor 3 Texture 6 Overall 3
Copper in color with a thin head. Malty aroma that’s sweet and not too hoppy. Not much flavor but very malty with some hops lurking in its depths. Drinkable but probably won’t order again.
Tried on 30 May 2010 at 14:56

6.6/10 Appearance 8 Aroma 6 Flavor 6 Texture 6 Overall 7.5
Also on tap at Shad festival. Decent body and hops. slightly bitter with some citrus and malt. i enjoyed it fine again might be slightly skewed due to how nice the weather and location were.
Tried from Draft on 17 May 2010 at 06:28

6.1/10 Appearance 6 Aroma 5 Flavor 6 Texture 6 Overall 7.5
On tap at the Shad festival on a beautiful sunday afternoon. Refreshing beer that pours a standard ale color with some caramel and malt. easy drinking session beer I had like 3.
Tried from Draft on 17 May 2010 at 06:25

6.8/10 Appearance 6 Aroma 6 Flavor 7 Texture 8 Overall 7
Scored this 12oz bottle as an extra in a trade with Brooha. Thanks BJ! Pours a transparent, copper amber with a thin, creamy, lacing white head. Aroma is malty, crackers, biscuit, some oranges, light citrus, light caramel, a little bread. Flavor is a good mix of sweet and bitter, caramel, cookie dough, oranges, lemons, biscuit, apples. Finish is crisp, medium carbonation.
Tried from Bottle on 18 Feb 2010 at 17:21